Metal Roofing vs. Asphalt Shingles

22 Jul, 2017
Metal Roofing Vs Asphalt

Metal Roofing Vs. Asphalt

When it comes to your home, the roof might be the most important surface since it protects your entire household from direct exposure to the elements and complements the look and feel of your property. In addition to catching most of the sunlight and providing insulation, the roof also helps to keep rain, hail and snow from entering your house. Since water is the leading cause of structural damage, having a roof that performs well under stress is critical to the status and functionality of your house.


Metal Roofing vs. Asphalt


If you have a damaged roof, you’ll probably have more to worry about than the cost of repair. Even though roofing repairs are rarely cheap, secondary damages can be a lot more costly. In addition to leaving your floor destroyed and furniture ruined, a leaky roof might lead to electrical issues if you are unlucky.


For a long time, asphalt shingles have been the preferred roofing material for residential use and suggesting anything else would have been strange. It’s only until recently that residential metal roofing systems started gaining popularity. As such, not many homeowners know which roofing solution best suits their homes.

Thinking about Metal Roofing


When it comes to roofing, homeowners will often consider price over other factors. However, there’s a lot more to keep in mind when choosing a roof for your home. When comparing metal roofing vs. asphalt shingles, you’ll want to consider durability, ease of installation, aesthetic value, and the level of maintenance required.


To help you make a well-informed decision, here’s a detailed look at metal roofing vs asphalt shingles.


Metal roofing vs asphalt shingles: Durability

Apart from the fact that it sheds snow easily and seals out water, metal is also resistant to extreme weather, fire, rot, and mildew. Also, metal roofs are not nearly as susceptible to venting problems as asphalt shingle roofs are, meaning poor ventilation affects them much less. With proper maintenance and care, metal roofs can outlast any asphalt roof. In fact, high-quality metal roofs can last up to 100 years when installed correctly, which is why hiring a reputable local metal roof contractor is important.


Metal Roofing vs Asphalt Chart


On the other hand, an asphalt shingle roof needs proper ventilation and might, therefore, call for a reliable intake system and a static vent system. Both the performance and longevity of a shingle roof are closely related to a well-ventilated attic, with poor ventilation shaving years off the roof’s lifespan. It is unfortunate that homeowners and roofers rarely include a reliable intake system. As a result, many asphalt shingle roofs have been known to fail early.


Metal roofing vs asphalt shingles: Weight

Metal is probably the lightest roofing material currently available. Although weight varies depending on the type, most varieties are as much as 40 percent lighter than asphalt shingle roofs. Most models weigh as little as 50-150 pounds per square. As a result, you will probably spend a lot less to engineer and install the roofing support and, therefore, save some money.


Asphalt Shingle Weight per Square


Asphalt shingles are often between 150 and 240 pounds per square, with some high-end varieties, like Architectural Shingles coming in at around 400 pounds per square.


Metal roofing vs asphalt shingles: Cost

Even though the price has reduced significantly over the years, a metal roof is still relatively expensive and can cost as much as 2-3 times the cost of an asphalt shingle roof, just like other premium materials. Copper, steel, zinc are much more expensive.


Roofing Material Costs Chart


When it comes to the initial cost, asphalt is certainly the least expensive roofing material. This low initial cost is asphalt’s biggest selling point, mostly because it matches the budget of many homeowners.


Metal roofing vs asphalt shingles: Styling options

Versatility is one of the unique qualities of a residential metal roofing system. With regards to appearance, metal roofs are available in two distinct forms, each featuring many variations. Manufacturers can fashion these metal roof panels and shingles into almost any roofing design imaginable, and this translates to unlimited styling options. As a matter of fact, this type of roofing can be made to imitate asphalt shingles.


Steel Shingles Colour Chart


Asphalt shingles offer plenty of roofing styles too, but not as much as metal roofs do. From the basic three-tab option to an array of designs imitating slate tiles and wood shakes among others, you will most likely find something that suits your home. Both types of roofing solutions come in a variety of colors.


Metal roofing vs asphalt shingles: Overall performance

In general, asphalt shingle roofs provide good uplift protection even though the product doesn’t always hold up well when exposed to high winds, driving rain, hail, or accumulated snow. Unfortunately, asphalt shingles are not low maintenance. Luckily, some manufacturers offer asphalt shingles that meet Energy Star requirements. Under federal standards, such systems qualify as cool roofs, and this makes them eligible for tax credits. Have a look at this infographic!


Metal vs Asphalt Infographic


Metal is a solid and reliable material, and you probably won’t find a roofing solution that can last longer. Aside from excellent heat conduction, metal roofing systems reflect the sun’s radiant heat and minimize midday heat gain, leading to reduced energy consumption. In addition to the class A fire rating, metal roofs provide superior protection and require minimal maintenance.


Metal roofing vs asphalt shingles: Installation

You’ll want a short installation process, particularly when you’ve had your roof stripped and there’s a storm coming. Asphalt shingles are relatively easy to install. In fact, you can tackle an asphalt shingle roofing project by yourself if you are good with tools and don’t mind the work. But because of safety concerns and warranty issues, we recommend that you don’t. Professional contractors can strip an old roofing system and install asphalt shingles within a day.


Steel Shingles Interlocking Design


Because they come in 12-36 inch panels or multiple sectioned shingles, metal roof installations can also be quick if your local metal roof contractor is well-equipped and has the necessary skills. Metal roofs complement a wide array of architectural designs and are often considered an upgrade. In addition to being a permanent solution, a metal roofing system can be installed on a gently pitched supporting structure without increasing the likelihood of any leaks. Some metal roofing such as Wakefield Bridge Steel Shingles also has a major advantage over asphalt and that is it’s 4-way interlocking design that creates strength and durability.



When dесiding on what tуре оf roofing ѕhinglеѕ tо choose, соnѕidеr уоur budgеt first, we are always willing to provide you with a Free Metal Roofing Estimate. Try to take into consideration the long-term effects of re-installing traditional shingles for both the environment and having to think about still replacing a roof down the road, that you just purchased. Wakefield Bridge Steel Shingle is the Last Roof You’ll Ever Buy. Period. You can finally rest at night and be down with the worry of ever having to replace your roof.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

18 + 2 =